Payroll

Square Payroll Review

By Admin
Updated August 31, 2026
Disclosure: MySMBGuide is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This does not influence our editorial rankings or recommendations — see our methodology.
8.0

Square Payroll

The ideal payroll solution for Square ecosystem businesses — seamless POS integration, automatic tip management, and transparent pricing make it a no-brainer for retail and restaurant owners.

Best for: Best for retail & restaurants

From $35/mo + $6/person/month

Visit Site

Pros

  • Seamless integration with Square POS and team management Automatic tip importing and allocation Transparent pricing with no hidden fees Contractor-only plan available with no base fee Fast payroll runs with minimal data entry

Cons

  • Limited value outside the Square ecosystem Minimal HR features beyond basic payroll No 24/7 customer support No dedicated payroll specialist option

Score Breakdown

Ease of Use
9.0
Features
7.6
Value for Money
8.2
Customer Support
7.5

More Payroll Reviews

Homebase Payroll

7.1/10

Best for: Best for hourly workforce

The best payroll choice for businesses managing hourly shift workers — the integrated scheduling-to-payroll pipeline eliminates manual data entry and reduces errors for restaurants, retail, and service businesses.

From $39/mo + $6/person/month

Read Review Visit Site

SurePayroll

7.3/10

Best for: Best for household employers

A reliable, budget-friendly payroll platform with a standout niche in household employer payroll — the go-to choice for anyone employing nannies, housekeepers, or domestic workers.

From $19.99/mo + $4/person/month

Read Review Visit Site

Wave Payroll

7.5/10

Best for: Best for freelancers & solopreneurs

A budget-friendly payroll solution that shines brightest within the Wave ecosystem — ideal for freelancers and micro-businesses that already use Wave for accounting and invoicing.

From $20/mo + $6/person/month

Read Review Visit Site